LEXINGTON, Ky. (AP) -- Billy Gillispie's second game as Kentucky's coach was one he'd rather forget -- and Gardner-Webb will remember for a long time.
Grayson Flittner scored 22 points to help Gardner-Webb beat the No. 20 Wildcats 84-68 Wednesday night in the 2K Sports College Hoops Classic.
"You can't just show up on the court and think you're going to beat somebody because you wear a certain jersey," said Gillispie, who turned 48 Wednesday. "We didn't play like a hunter tonight."
Instead, the Wildcats were the prey the entire game, falling behind 14-0 and never cutting the deficit under seven points.
"A lot of people will think this is a misprint, but I hope not," Gardner-Webb coach Rick Scruggs said. "I hope they get to see it and can enjoy it. It's going to take a few days to settle in."
Kentucky, Division I's winningest program, hadn't lost at home to an unranked nonconference foe since Dec. 3, 2005 against North Carolina.
"It's embarrassing when you lose, especially when it happens at home," Kentucky forward Perry Stevenson said. "We've just got to keep working hard and make sure it doesn't happen again."
The tournament, benefiting Coaches vs. Cancer, had been set up to send four top programs -- No. 3 Memphis, Connecticut, Oklahoma and Kentucky to New York next week to play in the semifinals.
However, instead of the Wildcats, Gardner-Webb, which finished 9-21 last season and tied for seventh in the Atlantic Sun Conference, will play the winner of Thursday night's game between Buffalo and Connecticut.
"We had confidence," Gardner-Webb forward Thomas Sanders said. "We wanted to play four minutes at a time and go timeout to timeout and give ourselves a chance to win in the final minutes. We ended up not needing to do that, though."
As it turned out, the Wildcats never had control of this game, trailing 14-0 just 4 minutes in, missing its first four shots and turning the ball over four times during that span.
Flittner hit a critical 3 midway through the first half that opened the Bulldogs' lead to 26-10.
Kentucky cut the deficit to seven less than 3 minutes later on a long jumper by Joe Crawford but would get no closer.
Crawford, a senior guard and regular starter last year, didn't crack the starting lineup for the second straight game under Gillispie despite leading the team with 20 points Tuesday against Central Arkansas.
Gardner-Webb led 38-27 at halftime, and Sanders began the second half with a three-point play to put the Wildcats deeper into a hole.
Gillispie opened his tenure as Kentucky coach Tuesday night with a 67-40 victory over Central Arkansas. The former Texas A&M coach took over the Wildcats after Tubby Smith left for Minnesota.
Gillispie was far more animated Tuesday night. Against Gardner-Webb, he just knelt on the sideline and shook his head. Afterward, he walked down the sideline to shake hands with each of the opposing players.
Although the Rupp Arena fans mildly applauded their support when the final horn sounded, the boo-birds came out early when the game appeared to be slipping away.
Among the lone bright spots for Kentucky were its two blue chip freshmen, power forward Patrick Patterson and guard Alex Legion.
Legion tried to single-handedly carry the Wildcats midway through the second half, hitting three 3-pointers and making a key steal in just over 2 minutes.
Patterson had 12 points and a game-high 12 rebounds, including 10 in the first half that accounted for half the Wildcats' total.
"They came to play," Patterson said of Gardner-Webb. "Obviously we didn't."
A night after holding Central Arkansas to 20 percent shooting -- the Wildcats' best defensive performance since 1995 -- Kentucky allowed the Bulldogs to make 53 percent.
Kentucky was ice cold shooting, hitting just 36 percent. Ramel Bradley led all scorers by tying a career high with 24 points and going 14-for-14 from the foul line.
But every time Kentucky made a basket, the Bulldogs seemed to make a bigger one.
"We just got our tails whipped." Gillispie said.